Can any store-bought peanut butter cookies compete with home-baked ones? ... Target steps up to the plate with a gluten-free, soft-baked peanut butter cookie from its Favorite Day bakery brand.

Mashed ranked 13 store-bought peanut butter cookies for flavor, texture, and value. The all-natural brand that came out on top as our favorite may surprise you.

We ranked and blindly tried 77 jars of peanut butte. ... Happy National Peanut Butter Day: 77 store-bought jars ranked worst to best. Updated: Jan. 24, 2024, 11:43 a.m.