We looked high and low for fun birthday party favors—including good-quality trinkets and special standalone items—that aren’t bound straight for the trash.

These thoughtful presents, from personalized keepsakes to luxury splurges, are perfect for ringing in 60 and celebrating this milestone birthday.

Birthdays are a big deal, so you have to pull out all the stops—including a delicious, home-cooked meal. What’s say you bring ...