10. 1936 Lincoln Wheat Cent Penny: Doubled-Die Obverse Value: $2,463 Don’t miss the 1936 Lincoln Wheat Cent Penny in your search for rare pennies, as one of these bad boys could be worth $2,222 ...

But he didn’t have double ear lobes, which is why a 1997 penny that appears to give him such a feature is worth some dough. One sold on eBay for $70. 10. 1999-P Connecticut Broadstruck Quarter .